Youโve found a therapist and the clinic isnโt in your insurance network. Will you be able to get Out of Network Physical Therapy? The main questions are will the therapy you need, the fee youโll pay, and your benefits align?
Patients should understand what catches them off guard; having out-of-network benefits doesnโt mean your insurer will reimburse the expected percentage of the clinicโs full price. Out of network benefits donโt always mean cost savings.
Out of network physical therapy, explained
Out-of-network physical therapy involves seeking services from a physical therapist that is not under a participation contract for your particular insurance program. You will still receive partial reimbursement on eligible bills, but the percentage will depend on your benefit package, deductible, maximum reimbursement and other coverages that apply.
A particular physical therapy center could be an in-network provider for one plan offered by an insurance provider while being an out-of-network service for another plan by the same insurance company. This is why โwe accept your insuranceโ does not give you an idea of how much you will need to pay. You can find this information out by consulting with the billing department at the facility or the medical billing services used by the facility.
There are typically 3 arrangements:
- You pay the full cost upfront and submit a claim to your insurer for reimbursement. The clinic provides an itemized superbill to help you submit the claim.
- The clinic submits the claim and receives payment under a permitted arrangement. You should confirm how your balance is determined.
- You forgo claim submission and pay for the service upfront.
Cash pay describes the method of payment. Out-of-network describes the relationship with the plan. A clinic can offer both, but the terms can vary. For example, cash pay may offer a discount or have no conditions for payment, while out-of-network may require documentation and/or reimbursement.
In-network vs. out-of-network PT
Neither model guarantees better treatment. A good comparison considers the therapist’s relevant skills, the treatment approach, financial accessibility and the support you receive.
| Factor | In-network PT | Out-of-network PT |
|---|---|---|
| Participation | Contract with your specific plan | No participation contract with that plan |
| Fees for covered care | Governed by the contract | Generally set by the clinic, subject to applicable rules |
| Patient cost | Plan deductible, copay or coinsurance | Potentially the full fee, reduced by any eligible reimbursement |
| Claim submission | Usually handled by the clinic | Patient or clinic, depending on arrangement |
| Amount above the allowed amount | Contract generally limits collection for covered services | May be your responsibility unless protections or agreements apply |
| Provider choice | Within the plan’s network | Beyond the network, subject to affordability and access |
| Individual attention | Depends on the clinic’s care model | Depends on the clinic’s care model |
| Insurance requirements | Applicable benefit rules remain | Applicable benefit rules remain if seeking reimbursement |
Ask about the actual service. Some clinics offer individual appointments; others use a team. A licensed physical therapist assistant has a different role from an unlicensed aide. Those roles shouldn’t be treated as interchangeable when comparing care.
Costs that create your bill
The clinic’s fee
There is not a single, uniform price for an out-of-network PT visit. Depending on where you live, there can be a significant amount of variance in prices. The same is true for specialization. It is not uncommon for clinics to have different prices for evaluations versus treatment.
When seeking pricing, it is best to request prices for both, describe the nature of your request, and ask whether there are any potential surprises.
Provide the same due diligence for packages. Check the terms for cancellation and refund. See if there are rules governing the treatment of unused visits.
A low price does not always guarantee a good deal, and care should be taken to assess whether the package contains services you do not need. It is reasonable to expect a care recommendation based on an assessment as opposed to the size of a prepaid package.
The planโs allowed amount
The amount that your insurance company will pay may be less than what the clinic charges. This amount is called the โallowedโ or โrecognizedโ amount. The insurance plan will often base their payment on the amount the insurance company will pay instead of the full amount billed by the clinic.
For example, the plan may say that they pay 80% of eligible amounts. This means that they will only pay 80% of a $100 allowed amount, even though the clinic charges $200. The difference between the clinicโs charge and the allowed amount may still be your responsibility to pay and is often called balance billing.
Your deductible and coinsurance
An out-of-network deductible may be separate from your in-network deductible. Meeting your in-network deductible does not guarantee that you have met your out-of-network deductible. Eligible claim amounts may be applied to your deductible, but this does not guarantee that you will receive a reimbursement.
Coinsurance is your percentage of an allowed amount. The insurance plan may pay 80% of an allowed amount. For a 40% coinsurance, this means that you are responsible for the remaining 40% of the allowed amount, after the insurance plan meets their 80% payment.
A reimbursement example with clear assumptions
The figures below are hypothetical, not a clinic quote or a promise of coverage. Assume a covered visit costs $200, the eligible allowed amount is $120 and the plan pays 60% of the eligible amount remaining beyond the deductible.
| Deductible situation | Estimated insurer payment | Your total cost |
|---|---|---|
| Deductible fully satisfied | $120 ร 60% = $72 | $200 โ $72 = $128 |
| $50 of deductible applies | ($120 โ $50) ร 60% = $42 | $200 โ $42 = $158 |
| At least $120 of deductible applies | $0 | $200 |
In the first example, your $128 consists of $48 coinsurance plus the $80 difference between the fee and allowed amount. In the second, it consists of $50 deductible, $28 coinsurance and the same $80 difference.
These calculations assume no additional exclusions, discounts, benefit limits or billing protections. A noncovered service may receive no reimbursement and no deductible credit.
For a covered claim under those assumptions:
Estimated reimbursement = eligible allowed amount remaining beyond the applicable deductible ร the insurer’s payment percentage.
Your estimated cost = clinic fee โ reimbursement.
Also check the out-of-pocket limit. A plan’s in-network maximum generally doesn’t cap elective out-of-network spending. Charges above the allowed amount may not count toward any separate out-of-network limit either.ย
Your plan’s benefits and coverage rules
PPO, POS, HMO and EPO plans
PPO plans typically give more freedom to go out-of-network, although you will pay extra. POS plans provide network benefits combined with referrals; HMOs and EPOs cover only network providers with a few exceptions like emergency cases.
The type of plan you have is just a beginning; the benefit documents will tell what services are covered. Just having a PPO card doesn’t mean that you can get reimbursement for physical therapy. Also, being restricted by the network doesn’t prevent an exception to be approved. The specialists at the clinic or their physical therapy billing services can check with your insurance company on your situation and costs.
You should be clear on what is wrong: the service is not covered by the plan, you have no out-of-network benefit, or the therapist is not within the network. It will be a different story to talk to your insurance company about each case. Being out-of-network doesn’t make the excluded service covered.
Referrals, authorization and direct access
Direct access is asking if a state allows a therapist to evaluate and treat you without a referral. Paying out-of-pocket to remove the need for a referral is a separate issue. APTA states direct access is the intersection of state practice acts, payer and organizational rules.
Find out what state laws apply to the clinic, and find out what the payer and organization rules are about referrals and authorization. You can suggest and request payment for services, and clarify what the payer’s rules are.
If you decide to privately pay, this may not always be required for a referral to the payer. You may still be required to meet certain licensing and clinical standards, and conditions the payer sets for a claim you submit.
Network exceptions and public programs
When a preferred provider is not available, find out from the insurer about a network-gap exception or single-case agreement. A network-gap exception is not automatic. Upon approval, get the name of the provider, the services to be rendered, the member cost-sharing and protection from balance billing.
Original Medicare has different rules from a commercial PPO. Physical therapists can not opt out of Medicare to privately contract for services that would otherwise be covered like some eligible practitioners. Nonparticipating status and opting out are different. Consult a Medicare-informed clinic regarding enrollment, covered services, and any notification of no coverage.
There are different rules for coverage under Medicare Advantage, Medicaid, Workers’ Compensation and other comparable coverage. Check the program requirements to be sure rather than assuming a commercial superbill arrangement covers the services for a particular patient.
Ask these questions to check your benefits
Go to your member portal or call the member service number on your card. Be prepared to give the clinic’s legal name and location, as well as the tax ID number for the provider. Explain to the clinic the provider numbers are for expected services, and the services actually rendered will ultimately determine what is billed.
Ask for answers to these questions:
- Does my plan cover outpatient physical therapy?
- Is the therapist and billing entity participating in this location and product?
- If not, do I have out-of-network physical therapy benefits?
- What is my deductible and what expenses will apply toward it?
- What percentage will I pay, and what will be the allowed amount?
- Are there limits (i.e. visit or unit) to my physical therapy, occupational therapy or speech benefits?
- Is an authorization, referral or medical necessity review required?
- Can a network exception be granted if adequate participating care is not available?
- What are the requirements for submitting a claim?
- What charges are allowed toward the spending limit?
- Who will be reimbursed?
Keep the reference number and written benefit information. A benefit check supports planning; it isn’t an unconditional payment guarantee. Eligibility, the actual services and the claim’s supporting documentation still matter.
Know more about what your costs will be
Ask your insurance questions to Find out about the costs in writing and any reimbursement help available.
Obtain Reimbursement by Submitting a PT Superbill
A superbill is an itemized record of services that may be used to substantiate an insurance claim. A superbill is not an approval, and a payment receipt alone may not contain all the information your plan requires.
1. Confirm the payment and submission arrangement
Ask if the clinic will file the claim on your behalf. If the clinic will file the claim, check who will get paid. Clarify how the clinic will resolve any patient overpayments.
If the clinic offers a self-pay discount, communicate the exact amount you paid to the clinic to help you save on your insurance claim. If you assume a reduced visit was paid at a higher amount, your insurance may deny coverage.
2. Obtain the required itemized documentation
Ask your plan what fields it needs. A typical claim packet may require the following:
- Patient identifying information matching the plan record.
- Treating Provider name, credentials and NPI.
- Billing entityโs name and tax ID.
- Service date and place of service.
- Diagnosis and procedure codes with modifiers and units.
- Itemized charges and payment information.
Check the document for missing or incorrect information. A payment receipt shows money was exchanged, but it does not show what service was rendered.
3. Complete the plan’s claim form
Use the form associated with your plan. Include the superbill, payment receipt, and any required referrals, authorizations or other insurance information. Follow your plan’s requirements for filing.
UnitedHealthcareโs member guidance explains both patient and provider submission arrangements and provides information about the services that will help the insurer process a claim. Other member guidance may require different information.
4. Retain proof of submission
Keep the claim packet and tracking/confirmation information. Check packet receipt via the planโs approved channel. If the clinic also submits claims, work with the billing contact to avoid duplicates.
Keep a simple record of the billed amount, claim number, and payment outcome to help track discrepancies. This can also help differentiate between a claim that was submitted but not paid and a claim that was adjudicated.
5. Read the explanation of benefits
Explanation of Benefits (EOB) reveals how your insurance company has handled your claim. Although it does not constitute your bill, an EOB can reveal the amount that might be due from you. Check the billed amount, the allowed amount, the payment by your insurer, deductibles applied, and denial reasons. In case there is anything that is out of sync with your benefits or treatment rendered, the billing department of the clinic or its Denial Management Services representative will be able to assist you in investigating the matter.
A zero-dollar insurance payment doesnโt always imply claim denial. The eligible amount could have been put towards the deductible, or the procedure could not be covered. Check the EOB for the reason codes.
6. Correct errors or use the appeal process
Check for a missing supporting document or attachment. A missing identifying information or support may require a corrected submission. A medical necessity or benefit determination may require an appeal. Follow the instructions provided by the plan regarding the appeal.
Ask the clinic to correct any inaccurate service information. Diagnosis/Procedure codes, units and treatment descriptions should not be changed for the sole purpose of obtaining coverage.
Is out-of-network physical therapy worth it?
An out-of-network therapist is a good option when they have skills or a treatment approach that better meets your needs and is not available in your current choices. For example, for pelvic health physical therapy and for vestibular rehabilitation or for a hand therapy condition or for sport specific rehabilitation.
Check on that expertise directly and ask about their training and education related to assessment and treatment. Also, ask about the outcomes measured to evaluate the progress.
Make sure your financial analysis includes realistic assumptions. Letโs say, two clinics each recommend an evaluation and 5 treatment sessions. One clinic tells you that your total out-of-pocket cost would be $240. The other clinic tells you that the total cost would be $1,200 and you would be reimbursed $300. At the second clinic your total out-of-pocket cost would be $900, not $300.
You would need to decide if the $900 would fit in your budget and also determine if it is reasonable to expect that the total cost would be lower if you paid the higher amount, or if the outcome would be better. The treatment plan should change based on the patientโs clinical need.
You should choose in-network care when available if your coverage allows you to afford it. Address the concern if the possibility of no reimbursement would make out-of-network physical therapy care unaffordable.
Use of HSA/FSA and private pay
You can pay for eligible medical physical therapy expenses from your HSA or FSA. Check with your plan administrator. You also may be able to pay for eligible physical therapy expenses out of pocket.
An expense can only be tax-favored and insurance-reimbursed once. You must coordinate any insurance payment with the administrator of the account in question. The fact that money is available in an account doesnโt mean that payment is no cost to the employee.
Assume that confidentiality must be requested for sensitive care. Cash payment does not remove the record of the service. HIPAA allows health plan providers to exercise discretion to not disclose protected health information in some circumstances. A request for confidentiality must be made, and the rules of HIPAA must be considered. Cash payment also does not mean there is no clinical documentation. Seeking insurance reimbursement requires sharing claim information with the health plan.
Questions to ask a Clinic
- What answers should a useful financial conversation give you?
- Who does the evaluation and treatment and what credentials do they have?
- Is care individual or shared and is it provided by a clinical team?
- What goals and measures will guide the treatment plan?
- What are the evaluation, treatment and other charges?
- What is the policy on refunds and cancellations?
- Do you offer an itemized โsuperbillโ? Can you submit a courtesy claim?
- Who do I contact for billing questions? Who can I contact to correct claim defects?
For self-pay patients, CMS indicates that patients have the right to receive a good faith estimate. Also, self-pay patients may be eligible to dispute a bill that is $400 or more over the self-pay good faith estimate.
No, don’t assume the No Surprises Act puts a cap on the surprise OON billing for an out of network (OON) visit to a freestanding physical therapy (PT) clinic. As mentioned earlier, the Act’s federal insurance protection only covers certain emergencies and situations that happen at a facility. State law and different scenarios could potentially change the outcome.
Common mistakes that lead to unexpected bills
Taking “we accept insurance” as proof of participation. Be sure to confirm the specific plan and the details of the billing arrangement.
Using the insurance reimbursement rate to determine the patient’s out of pocket cost. Ask about the allowed amount or the methodology, and be sure to include the deductible when giving an estimate.
Believing that all services provided will count towards the deductible. Not all expenses and charges will.
Thinking that providing care and getting insurance to preauthorize care are the same thing.
Not owning your claims. Be sure to confirm that the claims you submit are not duplicates.
Thinking that a refund of a package is guaranteed. Be sure you can truly afford the package if you don’t receive reimbursement, and read the terms of the refund.
Find care that fits your needs and budget
Talk to about your condition, your goals and your budget concerns. Ask for an evaluation at a flat fee with reimbursement details.
Frequently asked questions
Will insurance reimburse out-of-network physical therapy?
It may, if your plan includes an applicable benefit and the claim meets its requirements. Payment depends on the allowed amount, deductible, coinsurance and coverage conditions. A superbill supports a claim but doesn’t guarantee payment. Some eligible claims produce deductible credit rather than reimbursement.
Is cash-pay physical therapy the same as out-of-network care?
No. Cash pay describes paying the clinic directly, often without using insurance. Out-of-network describes the provider’s relationship with your plan. You may pay an out-of-network clinic and seek reimbursement, but that depends on the clinic’s arrangement, accurate documentation and your benefits.
Do I need a referral for an out-of-network physical therapist?
State direct-access rules may permit evaluation or treatment without a referral, subject to conditions. Your insurer can have separate payment requirements. Confirm the applicable clinical access rules with the clinic and the referral or authorization conditions with your specific plan.
Will the full clinic fee count toward my deductible?
Not necessarily. Your plan may apply only an eligible allowed amount to its out-of-network deductible. Charges above that amount and noncovered services may not count. Ask which accumulator receives credit, and confirm that treatment on the EOB matches the benefit explanation.
Can I use an HSA or FSA for out-of-network PT?
Eligible medical expenses may qualify even when the provider is out of network. Keep the required records and confirm the service’s eligibility with the account administrator. Insurance and tax-favored accounts cannot both reimburse the same expense; coordinate payments to avoid duplicate reimbursement.
Is out-of-network physical therapy worth the extra cost?
It can be when the therapist’s relevant skills, care approach and accessibility fit your needs and the total cost is affordable. Compare actual clinic services and realistic insurance estimates. An appropriately skilled in-network therapist may be an equally suitable choice with a lower financial burden.
Exercise caution with expectations spelled out
The out-of-network physical therapy service becomes relatively easy to determine when you have the exact cost of the clinic, the payment process used by your insurance coverage, and how much you would pay out-of-pocket if the coverage does not pay anything. Add that to the expertise of the therapist and his/her proposed treatment program.
There is no need for decision-making on the grounds that the particular type of billing process ensures better quality of care.





